Get a taste of the old country at the many delicious and award-winning Italian restaurants in St. Augustine. Delicious pastas, pizzas, chicken dishes, and more await visitors at the local Italian restaurants in town. Enjoy fresh-made dishes prepared with local ingredients! There are great Italian eateries that offer quick bites as well as charming, sit-down restaurants serving up all the Italiano you could want.

Papa Harry's Diner

(904) 825-4315
4508 Highway US 1 N

4 review(s)

Papa Harry's Diner located on Highway US 1 North in historic St. Augustine serves up a delicious menu and a fun, casual dining atmosphere. This small restaurant serves up large meals, such as Eggplant Parmesan, Catfish Salad and more!

Al's Pizza

(904) 824-4383
1 St. George Street

Al's Pizza brings their delectable menu, homemade sauces, scratch-made dough and more to the nation's oldest city! Enjoy great Italian food at Al's, located on St. George Street in historic downtown.

La Pentola Restaurant

(904) 824-3282
58 Charlotte St

5 review(s)

For a refined atmosphere, exquisite dining, and authentic Italian and Mediterranean food come to La Pentola in downtown St. Augustine.

Amici Italian Restaurant

(904) 461-0102
1915 A1A South

3 review(s)

For authentic and delicious Italian food made from scratch come by Amici's Restaurant and enjoy a cozy dining atmosphere as well.

Pizza Time

(904) 819-0133
124 St. George St.

9 review(s)

Pizza Time located on St. George Street in historic downtown St. Augustine serves great New York style pizza! With fresh ingredients and a true New York style crust it is no wonder this Italian restaurant draws in a crowd.


(904) 819-1760
415 Anastasia Blvd.

Newly reopened in its original location, Fratelli's is the quintessential neighborhood Italian restaurant with cozy atmosphere and all your favorite Italian-American specialties.

King's Bistro

(904) 687-3963
6 Mackey Lane

King's Bistro provides gourmet food, a charming atmosphere and excellent service! This quaint, unassuming restaurant is located in a house off West King Street just outside of historic downtown.


(904) 825-2627
117 St. George Street

5 review(s)

Order quick-service pizza at the counter, or sit down for a full dining experience at the Chianti Room.

Casa Benedetto's

(904) 471-5999
6357 A1A South

5 review(s)

Casa Benedetto's Italian Caffe offers traditional authentic homemade Italian cuisine carefully prepared from old family recipes.

New York Pizza Co.

(904) 825-4545
163 Palencia Village Drive #101

2 review(s)

New York Pizza Company located at Palencia Village in historic Saint Augustine is serving up a slice of New York style! Come by for a delicious slice of pizza any day of the week.

Antonio's Pizza - Vilano

(904) 342-8859
105 Yacht Club Dr.

Try authentic and fresh pizza at this New York style pizzeria. They also offer other Italian entrees.

Cino's Pizza

(904) 940-4445
425 West Town Place #114

1 review(s)

Cino's Pizza is an Italian restaurant in St. Augustine, located at the World Golf Village. Here customers will find a variety of oven baked pizzas. Both New York Style and Sicilian style pizza is served at this restaurant.

Antonio's Pizza - A1A Beach Blvd.

(904) 471-5200
378 A1A Beach Blvd.

Try authentic and fresh Italian food at this New York style pizzeria. Always offering hot, fresh pizza made with fresh ingredients.

Borrillo's Pizza & Subs

(904) 829-1133
88 San Marco Ave.

1 review(s)

Borrillo's Pizza and Subs serves New York style pizza in the heart of St. Augustine, Florida. Open for lunch and dinner, this little pizza place is loved by locals and visitors alike.

Spanky's II

(904) 794-1888
4255 US Highway 1 S

1 review(s)

Spanky's II in historic St. Augustine off US Highway 1 offers great Italian food and great service. Here you can relax and enjoy their fun, family friendly atmosphere.

Chianti Room

(904) 825-4100
60 Charlotte Street

2 review(s)

Order Italian plates, appetizers, drinks, and more at this dining spot just off St. George Street.

DeLeon Pizza

(904) 794-1917
84 Theatre Drive

2 review(s)

DeLeon Pizza is a located next to the Epic Theatre complex in St. Augustine, Florida. A great little restaurant to grab a slice or share a whole pizza pie, either before or after a movie next door!

Tony's Pizza on San Marco

(904) 823-3775
138 San Marco Avenue

Taste a slice of Italy at Tony's Pizza! This restaurant offers a delicious variety of Italian food including Greek Gyros! Enjoy a slice of freshly baked pizza, a tasty sub, wings or a gyro from Tony's. Come by for lunch or dinner every day.

Cucina Giovanni

(904) 823-8999
2730 State Road 16

Cucina Giovanni Italian Restaurant offers classic Italian food at affordable prices. This St. Augustine restaurant is conveniently located next to the Saint Augustine Outlet Malls and I-95.

Tony's Pizza

(904) 471-8660
6975 A1A South

2 review(s)

Tony's Pizza located in Crescent Beach in historic Saint Augustine, Florida offers authentic and tasty Italian food! Enjoy a great pizza, sub, calzone, pasta dinner, and more at Tony's.